Gwen Stefani is no stranger to the spotlight, but her recent performance of “Somebody Else’s” on The Voice stirred up mixed reactions. While some fans celebrated her unique style and emotional delivery, others weren’t as kind, pointing out flaws they felt detracted from the performance. Let’s dive into the details, the critiques, and what makes Gwen Stefani’s artistry stand out despite the controversy.
The Performance That Sparked Debate
On a recent episode of The Voice, Gwen Stefani performed “Somebody Else’s”, a track from her latest album Bouquet. The performance featured an elaborate set designed to resemble a gas station, complete with a parked station wagon, a Diesel gas pump, and backup dancers in avant-garde cowboy outfits.
Stefani herself donned a glittering top, denim shorts, and tan cowboy boots as she emerged from the car to deliver a high-energy performance. Her dynamic stage presence and visible emotional investment in the song captivated the live audience, who cheered and danced along to the beat.
But while the in-studio reaction was overwhelmingly positive, the online response told a different story.
The Online Backlash: A Mixed Bag of Opinions
Social media users and online viewers were quick to voice their criticisms of Stefani’s performance. Many took issue with her vocals, particularly her pronunciation.
- One viewer remarked, “Her enunciation isn’t up to par. I wish I could have understood the words better.”
- Another quipped, “Her voice is irritating, and she sings through her nose.”
- Some even went as far as to suggest that Stefani should consider retiring, with one comment stating, “She’s adorable, but it’s time to hang up the mic.”
The criticism wasn’t confined to YouTube; Facebook and Instagram users also weighed in. While some comments focused on technical aspects, others veered into personal territory, questioning her overall talent and relevance.
Support Amid Criticism
Gwen Stefani singing “Somebody Else’s.” | Source: YouTube/The Voice
Amid the wave of negativity, many fans came to Stefani’s defense, celebrating her performance as a return to her roots.
- One Instagram user wrote, “This song is fantastic, and the performance was fire!”
- Another commented, “Love this one—more like the older version of Gwen.”
These fans highlighted her unique style, noting that while her voice might not align with traditional expectations, it’s her individuality that has always set her apart.
The Song’s Journey: From Reluctance to Spotlight
“Somebody Else’s” wasn’t initially intended to feature on Bouquet, Stefani’s fifth studio album. In an interview with Rolling Stone, she revealed that the song’s subject matter—a bold message directed at an ex—didn’t fit with the album’s overarching theme of love and renewal.
However, Stefani ultimately decided to include the track, recognizing the importance of juxtaposing darkness and light. She explained, “You needed to see a little bit of the dark to see the light.”
What Makes “Somebody Else’s” Unique?
The song serves as the opening track of Bouquet, setting the stage for a deeply personal album. With its confessional tone, “Somebody Else’s” bridges the gap between Stefani’s 2016 album This Is What the Truth Feels Like and her new chapter, which she describes as “a new lease on life with Blake Shelton.”
The accompanying music video, released in November 2024, features striking imagery that underscores the song’s narrative. From tossing an ex’s belongings out the window to vivid, symbolic visuals, the video complements the track’s raw emotion.
my fifth studio album, 'Bouquet’, will be in full bloom on November 15th 💐
— Gwen Stefani (@gwenstefani) September 18, 2024
pre-order 'Bouquet’ available NOW exclusively on my online store, including a limited edition blue vinyl. the first single, 'Somebody Else’s,' will be available everywhere starting TOMORROW at 9pm PST /… pic.twitter.com/3NGVqTIqQi
A Look at the Criticism: Is It Justified?
Criticisms of Stefani’s performance largely centered around her vocal delivery, with many highlighting her distinct tone and pronunciation. However, these traits have always been hallmarks of her style, dating back to her early days with No Doubt.
While some may find her voice unconventional, it’s precisely this uniqueness that has made her a standout artist for decades. Gwen Stefani doesn’t conform to cookie-cutter standards of pop; instead, she embraces her individuality, which resonates with her loyal fanbase.
Why Stefani’s Evolution Matters
In discussing her journey to creating Bouquet, Stefani noted that the album reflects eight years of personal growth, healing, and transformation. For an artist with a career spanning decades, staying true to oneself while evolving is no small feat.
Gwen Stefani singing and interacting with fans during her performance on “The Voice” in 2024. | Source: Getty Images
Critics may focus on one performance, but Stefani’s legacy speaks for itself. From her ska-punk roots to her pop reinvention, she’s consistently pushed boundaries and taken risks.
The Role of Social Media in Shaping Perception
Performances in the digital age are subject to instant scrutiny. Social media amplifies voices—both positive and negative—creating an environment where even minor flaws can become major talking points.
Stefani’s case is no exception. While the live audience cheered her on, online viewers dissected every detail, showcasing the disparity between in-person reactions and online commentary.
Gwen Stefani | Source: Getty Images
Conclusion: A Legacy of Boldness and Creativity
Gwen Stefani’s performance of “Somebody Else’s” on The Voice may have divided opinions, but it also reaffirmed her status as an artist unafraid to take risks.
In a world where conformity often reigns, Stefani stands out for her authenticity, creativity, and willingness to explore new territory. Whether you loved or critiqued her performance, one thing is certain: Gwen Stefani continues to make an impact.
As fans and critics debate her latest offering, Stefani remains true to her journey, proving that artistry is about more than just hitting the right notes—it’s about staying genuine to your story.
